Altria Group, Inc., et al. v. Good, et al.

Case Details

Status: Defeat
Docket No: 07-562
NCLC Involvement: Petitioner
Solicitor General Involvement: Respondent
Sub-Issue: Legal Reform
Industry: Consumer Goods
Sub-Industry: Tobacco
Term: 2008 Term
Oral Argument Date: October 06, 2008
Vote: 5-4
Opinion: Stevens
Lower Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit

Question(s) Presented

Whether state-law challenges to FTC-authorized statements regarding tar and nicotine yields in cigarette advertising are expressly or impliedly preempted by federal law.

NCLC's Position

NCLC filed twice in this case: once to support cert. and once on the merits. This case is also known as Philip Morris USA Inc., et al. v. Good, et al.

NCLC filed briefs in support of the petitioner, appealing a First Circuit ruling that federal law does not preempt state law causes of action challenging FTC-authorized statements. In this case, plaintiffs challenged FTC-approved cigarette labels such as “light” or “lower tar and nicotine” as misleading because the labels failed to account for “real-world” consumer behavior, such as taking larger puffs, to compensate for the lower nicotine content. NCLC argued that the Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act expressly preempts state-law requirements or prohibitions, including tort actions, “based on” smoking or health with respect to the advertising or promotion of cigarettes. When Congress enacted uniform labeling standards, it did so in order to promote efficiency, reduce barriers to interstate commerce, and prevent consumer confusion.

Case Outcome

Disagreeing with NCLC, the Supreme Court held that neither the Cigarette Labeling Act's preemption provision nor the Federal Trade Commission's actions preempt state-law fraud claims regarding the advertisement of tar and nicotine levels.

Justices in Majority
Breyer
Ginsburg
Kennedy
Souter
Stevens
Justices in Minority
Alito
Roberts
Scalia
Thomas
Procedural History

Amicus brief on the merits filed 4/7/08. Oral argument held 10/6/08. Decided 12/15/08.

Case Documents