Golan, et al. v. Holder, Jr., et al.

Term: 2011 Term
Oral Argument Date: October 05, 2011
Vote: 6-2
Opinion: Ginsburg

Question(s) Presented

Section 514 of the Uruguay Round Agreements Act of 1994 (Section 514) did something unique in the history of American intellectual property law: It "restored" copyright protection in thousands of works that the Copyright Act had placed in the Public Domain, where they remained for years as the common property of all Americans. The Petitioners in this case are orchestra conductors, educators, performers, film archivists and motion picture distributors, who relied for years on the free availability of these works in the Public Domain, which they performed, adapted, restored and distributed without restriction. The enactment of Section 514 therefore had a dramatic effect on Petitioners' free speech and expression rights, as well as their economic interests. Section 514 eliminated Petitioners' right to perform, share and build upon works they had once been able to use freely.

The questions presented are:

1. Does the Progress Clause of the United States Constitution prohibit Congress from taking works out of the Public Domain?

2. Does Section 514 violate the First Amendment of the United States Constitution? 

Case Outcome

The court held that Section 514 of the Uruguay Round Agreements Act does not exceed Congress’ authority under the Copyright Clause; and the First Amendment does not inhibit the restoration authorized by §514.

Justices in Majority
Ginsburg
Kennedy
Roberts
Scalia
Sotomayor
Thomas
Justices in Minority
Alito
Breyer
Procedural History

Cert. granted 3/7/11.  Decided 1/18/12.

Case Documents